American Birthdays by Elizabeth Kate Switaj

Cherry was America’s least favorite pie. Her mother made it every year for her father’s birthday because “daddy doesn’t like cake.” America had to wash the bowls, the wooden spoon, the plates and finally the Pyrex dish. Her brother got to “contribute” by climbing the tree in the yard and picking the cherries.

One year, America complained that it wasn’t fair. Her mother said, “Just be grateful we have a sink you can reach from your chair.”

Another year, America asked for apple pie for her own birthday. Her mother said, “Just be grateful you have friends here” and served chocolate cake with buttercream roses.

Yet another year, America asked why her family had moved to a country that made war on theirs. Her mother said, “Just be grateful you were born here.”

The year before she left for college, America asked if it could have been American weapons that made her be born without legs. Her mother said, “Just be grateful. If we got the visas three months later, you might not have had arms. Six months later, you might not have been born.”

For her first birthday away from home, America tried to make an apple pie, but it burned. She bought red velvet cake instead and told herself she was lucky that she didn’t miss the last accessible bus back from the store.

.

Return to This Week’s Flash

8 Comments

Filed under Elizabeth Kate Switaj

8 responses to “American Birthdays by Elizabeth Kate Switaj

  1. Al McDermid

    So sad, rendered more so by the protagonist’s name. “Just be grateful. If we got the visas three months later . . .” Wow.

  2. Oh God – what a sad story! This is more about ‘the damned’ than least favourite! I am wondering was her mother just cheery or cruel?!

  3. A lot of metaphor here that changes the meaning with each reading.

  4. Quenby Larsen

    “She bought red velvet cake instead and told herself she was lucky that she didn’t miss the last accessible bus back from the store.”

    Yes. How small our hopes and desires become when we are denied them over and over and told to feel things we do not feel. A wonderful story. I look forward to reading more.

  5. libbywalkup

    The cycles we end up in.

    Lovely and sad.

  6. So many levels of meaning. A different take on each read. Provocative stuff. The various cakes is such a fascinating armature for the story. Peace…

  7. Pingback: Week #25 – least favorite « 52|250 A Year of Flash

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s